Beyond Magenta:
Transgender Teens Speak Out was published by Susan Kuklin in 2014, which
involves the profiles and series of interviews of six young transgender teens. Their
gender identities, family relationships, transition processes, societal
acceptance, rejection experiences, and future ambitions. However, the book is unsuited
to 14 years old because it contains explicit language, violent actions, and
detailed descriptions. The sad part is it includes children as young as six
years old engaged in oral sex.
Beyond Magenta:
Transgender Teens Speak Out is the compilation of six transgender teens, namely
Jessy, Christina, Mariah, Cameron, Nat, and Luke. These teenagers are in doubt
of their gender orientations and feel trapped in the wrong bodies.
Jessy
was born a girl from a respected family in Thailand. Jessy's father's a
diplomat in the USA. At a young age, Jessy realized that he was not comfortable
with his gender. Jessy preferred suits and ties over dresses. When Jessy
revealed that he wanted to transition- from a woman to a man, his parents
accommodated the idea. Jessy's parents wanted him to be happy with his choices
and be successful. They supported his decision to take testosterone and have
therapy for his transition. Now, he is just like any other man, very masculine:
his voice, facial hair, even his skin texture is thicker, rougher, and his body
is more muscular. He is currently in a relationship with Nan.
Christina, who is
Latina came from a Catholic family. She began her transition in an all-boys
Christian school. Christina was constantly bullied in elementary and high
school and encountered problems with her teachers. Christina even recalled the
fight on a subway when she was provoked by other passengers' transphobia in New
York City. She also shared other students in school freaked out because she
looked like a girl and moved against gender boundaries. Christina describes her
transition from male to female as more complicated; however, she was eventually
accepted by her mother and brother.
Mariah is a
biracial, Black, and Cherokee Indian who requested not to have a photograph
included in the book. Mariah emphasized her struggle to understand her sexual
identity and gender expression. Mariah recalls that she used to kiss guys since
she was six years old, have sex with them, and perform oral sex. She thought it
was normal for her age. Mariah also makes out with girls to avoid being bullied
at school because everyone encourages her to do so. In addition, Mariah shared
that perverts or pedophiles made a move with her while touching themselves. She
admitted that she somehow got swayed, but she ran away. Mariah shared her heartbreaking account of
being moved between foster homes, treatment centers, hospitals, and psychiatric
centers.
Cameron is an
aspiring doctor and a social activist. They are from Westchester County but
"not one of the rich, white Westchester communities you hear about,"
as they put it. Cameron prefers the pronoun "they" and describes
themselves as pansexual. Cameron explains that gender is one variable in a
person's identity, and sexual orientation is another variable. Personal
orientation and sexual identity are not connected so being trans is not the
next step to being gay. Cameron believes that they are similar in that they are
both breaking gender rules.
Nat is an European-American who was confirmed as
an intersex adolescent by their doctors. Nat's struggle with identity led to
severe depression. Nat has been confused with his feeling all along. Nat
embodies gender flexibility and prefers the pronouns (they and them) to avoid
gendered ones. They believe that gender is three-dimensional: males float around
somewhere, females float around somewhere else, and some people don't float at
all—they swim". Nat was fascinated to discover that they are not only emotionally,
psychologically, and spiritually both sexes; they were physically both
sexes." They eventually moved out of their parent's home, where they seemed
more content with their life.
Luke discovered
his identity through theater, as he was delegated as a trans man after first
joining the company. He finds it more manageable to speak his mind on stage
from an audience of strangers than in conversation with people he knows. Luke's
experience in theater allowed him to research the possibility of trans man identities.
He also revealed that his family accepted him being gay; however, being trans is
different because they were unaware. Luke's story separates other events in his
life into scenes, showing his commitment and gratitude to the theater and its
effect on his life.
Many readers would claim that the
story of the teens in Beyond Magenta is interesting since it represents the
voice of the unheard young adults who struggle with their gender identities.
People believe that this book is inspirational and empowers the most neglected
topic in society: gender diversity or LGBTQ+. In addition, the book delivers
awareness to the readers that the issue of gender identity is factual and
relevant. Many also commend the truthful account of the teenagers in their
family relationships, transition processes, and experiences. However, the book
contains explicit language, violent acts, and graphic descriptions, which is
inappropriate for 14 years old and up readers.
In the same way,
sex and genitalia are openly discussed. Further, the level of detail about the
teens' lives in the book is hard to understand by other teenagers. As parents,
would you like to expose your children to a book with such content?
We have to realize that this book
is intended for young adults. We have to consider that our children may have a
limited understanding of topics represented in the book. Our children may not be able to determine
whether the given concept is good or bad behavior. How do we expect them to
absorb all the presented experiences of the teens in the book? Do you realize
the effect it may bring to the young minds of our children?
As parents, we
need to protect our children from the awful reading materials that confuse
their young minds. Let us remind ourselves that adolescence is the most crucial
stage of an individual's life. This kind of book will pollute the imagination
and beliefs of our children; hence we must be critical of the books that our
children will read in school.
We have to act now
before it's too LATE!